data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a7be6/a7be6b96c973df5ca1174e089e2945d6ab114841" alt="" |
Shinnosuke -
:
Crayon Shinchan and Japanese Society
Nora Stevens
|
: An introduction
Crayon Shinchan, a
created by Usui Yoshito, recounts the adventures of one very high-spirited
five-year-old boy and his encounters with his friends, teachers, parents,
and pet dog. Most of the stories told in its pages seem realistic enough,
but exactly how true-to-life are the relationships contained within? Moreover,
does this manga accurately reflect or possibly even influence Japanese
society, and if so, how?
My observations are based
on the first thirteen volumes of manga collections dating from 11 May
1992 to 26 November 1995. These books contain about 70 percent of all
the Shinchan manga that have been published. There have been more developments
in the story after that date, but this paper does not cover any of them.
: The Noharas
On
first sight, the Nohara family appears fairly typical: a housewife mother,
salaryman father, and their 1.5 children. (Their one son can be quite
a handful.) Look a little closer and one can see what's really going on.
|
Nohara
Shinnosuke, a.k.a. Shinchan, age 5
"
" Shinchan's the star of the show, and boy, does he know it.
His hobbies tend toward the indecent, and include such gems as the
,
, and one of the few that are actually shown in the strip, the
(right). In fact, he seems to be able to concentrate best when his
pants are half off (volume 9, page 111); maybe it's his version
of a thinking cap.
When not performing
his physical comedy, he's often found propositioning young women
at least four or five times his age ("
"). God knows why. It gets him into trouble with his mother,
though, perhaps because she sees her husband in him. More about
that later. He also has a propensity for looking up women's skirts
and remarking upon the color and design of their underwear ("Oh!
Polka dots!").
He's in the
class at Action Kindergarten, where he makes absurd costumes during
crafts hour and, given the option, would most likely choose to spend
his recess time playing dead out on the playground (below).
|
|
|
He also
tends to not act like a child when he sighs "
" at a hot spring or complains about "kids these days" as though
he weren't a kid himself. Often his friends have to remind him.
Apart from his quirks
(and there are many), he actually is a fairly normal five-year-old:
he's a fan of TV sci-fi heroes
and Kantam Robo, popular among most boys his age. He has absolutely
no interest in girls--at least, kindergarten girls; in fact, upon
receiving a love letter from a fellow student, he whines, "But I'm
not attracted to kids!" He balks at washing dishes and taking
out the dog. What is most interesting, though not as far-out as the
other differences, is that he rarely screams, rarely cries or throws
tantrums, and is often punished--all of which is a far cry from the
real Japanese youngsters I've seen.
Also typical is his
misuse of the language. Shinchan calls out "
" when he comes home from school and uses mixed-up greetings like
. His written language is full of misspellings and strangely-written
characters, and when he overhears someone older saying something that
sounds pretty sophisticated, he'll try to repeat it, but fails miserably,
switching around syllables and words to no end. He also uses
(nonstandard even for adults) to refer to himself when most five-year-old
boys use boku, and prefers
to hai. |
Nohara
Misae, age 29
Shinchan's housewife
mother, who has become very short-tempered after five years of dealing
with her son. And who can blame her? A five-year-old calling his mother
by her first name? In front of people? Harassing her about what
was missing from her chest being applied liberally to her behind?
Misae is unlike the Japanese
mothers I've seen in that she will not hesitate to verbally and physically
reprimand her son in public as well as in private, almost to the point
where a call to Child Services may be in order . . . but not quite.
Then again, there are happy times, too, and the two have managed to
get along so far without killing one another.
Misae tends to bring
Shinchan just about everywhere, probably because leaving him home alone
usually results in some sort of household catastrophe. However, excursions
with Mom just mean ample opportunities to be embarrassed (and Shinchan
usually requests compensation in the form of action figures or Chocobee
snacks).
She takes care of her
household; tends to her husband and child when they're sick; rides Shinchan
to school when he misses the bus (which is most of the time); takes
an umbrella out to her husband when it's raining; cleans, shops, and
otherwise works like a dog. Like the typical Japanese housewife, she
definitely earns her afternoon naps.
Occasionally, she tries
playing pretend or acting in a fun-kid sort of way to get Shinchan to
be a bit more enthusiastic--for example, when the Noharas went fishing,
Misae started talking excitedly (for Shinchan's benefit) about the possibility
of catching mermaids and being led to their secret castles. "Geez, mom,"
Shinchan replied with a snort, "act your age." |
|
|
Nohara
Hiroshi, age 35
The breadwinning salaryman
father of the Nohara clan, Hiroshi is a
for a medium-sized company and quite surprisingly still manages
to have time to spend with his family. Shinchan probably has inherited
some of his lecherous habits from Hiroshi, who ogles pretty young things
just as often as his son (and is chastised by Misae just as often, too).
However, he is faithful to his wife, but only when awake: his
dreams often deal with an office romance (and are usually rudely interrupted
by Shinchan's antics).
Where Misae is the stern
disciplinarian, Hiroshi barely lays a
hand on his son to reprimand him, but rather attempts to defuse Misae's
temper with a few "
"s now and again. When Misae asks him to properly scold Shinchan,
Hiroshi tends to just sit down with the boy and tell him (tiredly) to
shape up. He's also able to convince Shinchan to go places he would
normally not want to go by telling him about the beautiful women who
are bound to be there, although this tends to incur his wife's wrath.
His weak point, as far
as being belittled by his son goes, is his smelly socks, which are often
used to wake up, threaten, and/or punish any member of the family, including
the dog.
He calls Misae by her
first name, not "
". This, I believe, is a step in the right direction. Though we've
been reading in Japanese class about dads these days being terrible
role models for their children, Hiroshi generally sets a good example
for Shinchan, rarely coming home drunk and hardly ever using violence.
|
A young puppy, found abandoned by Shinchan and friends and adopted as
part of the Nohara family. As his name indicates, he's white (Shinchan's
imagination apparently doesn't extend to pet names), and looks a lot
like a cotton candy. (Quoth Shinchan, upon leaving Shiro in a stranger's
care for a few moments, "He looks like cotton candy, but don't eat him.")
Shinchan promised to
take care of Shiro, as all five-year-old prospective pet owners do,
but doesn't seem to like it very much. He's gotten some laughs out of
the poor puppy by putting cold masks on him, though, and has taught
Shiro two tricks:
, wherein Shiro scratches himself, and
, when Shiro curls up like a big ball of cotton candy and rolls
around.
|
|
: At school
John
Singleton tells us that "underlying [the 'good child' reinforcement approach
in kindergarten] is the assumption that a child is basically good" (14).
This must be the reason why Shinchan's teachers merely grit their teeth
and tell him nicely to please put his pants back on. Looking at this from
an American standpoint, I can't say I expected corporal punishment, but
I at least expected some sort of estrangement from the group as retribution
for the more offensive things Shinchan does. Then again, perhaps being
Shinchan and doing what he does is considered sufficient estrangement.
|
The
Himawari class appears to be closely-knit. They have camping trips
and field trips together, and the principal (who is, Shinchan is convinced,
) is even (mostly) willing to be a part of the children's game
of playing house (left; volume 8, page 62). Group identity is reinforced
when baseball games and marathons bring Himawari together to compete
with the
class--and through determination, effort, and, most of all, cooperation,
Himawari just can't lose.
Out of the entire Himawari
class, Shinchan has four close friends: Kazama-kun, the serious one;
Nene-chan, the girl; Masao-kun, the crybaby, who's prone to being
bullied; and Bô-chan, the runny-nosed kid who says very little
but is always around. (Bô-chan always volunteers for the parts
of pet dogs or cats when the group plays house. Perhaps he's a bit
stranger than Shinchan.) They're always ready to lend one another
a helping hand, defending Masao from bullies or helping Nene find
her cat, although Kazama is equal to Misae in his complete lack of
patience with Shinchan. (In volume 10, page 86, he watches Shinchan
be his crazy self and admits, "Sometimes I really envy that kid .
. . but I wouldn't want to be him.")
Iwama, though writing
about secondary schools in Japan, points out that "students remain
in the same classroom" all day (79) and eat their lunches together
in that same classroom with their teachers. This is also true in Crayon
Shinchan, where the teacher checks to see that everyone has the
proper
and the proper tools with which to eat before digging in (9:55).
|
Kindergarten is not too
young for
, though only one of Shinchan's friends attends a cram school (for
English), and he's the annoyingly serious one with a
(10:86) as described in The Learning Gap, page 82. Juku
takes precedence over play for Kazama-kun, which is surely odd for a kindergartner--meaning
he, too, is out-of-group in at least one way.
In thirteen volumes of
manga, Shinchan's teachers have visited his home twice, not because he
had specifically done anything wrong or because there was any sort of
a problem (though there probably was, knowing him), but because it was
that time of the school year, when teachers stop by to discuss their students'
progress with the students' parents. This reinforces the closely-knit
bond between the three parties and also helps to lend a homey atmosphere
to school and a friendly air to one's instructors.
: Home life
The
Nohara family plays together and stays together. Contrary to what was
mentioned in The Learning Gap, which said American parents take
their children on outings about seven times more often than Japanese parents
do (75), Mr. and Mrs. Nohara have never gone anywhere without their son.
When Misae won a trip to Guam, all three Noharas went; they go to zoos,
spas, art museums, and baseball games as a family. Perhaps this is becoming
more common in Japan nowadays, but certainly the stereotypical image is
of the dad too busy with work or too tired of it to do anything with the
family when he is home, which isn't often, due to extended overtime
and group-building company activities. Then again, the story wouldn't
be as fun if the main rabble-rousing character weren't in it.
Since Hiroshi rarely comes
home late, the Noharas can usually
eat dinner together, whether at home or at a restaurant. Even dining at
fancier restaurants is a family affair, even though I think that's not
quite the norm in real-life Japan--the children would be staying over
the neighbors' or at Auntie's house.
Misae and Hiroshi do have
their quarrels, but they always, always kiss and make up. When Hiroshi
was asked to take a month-long business trip to Osaka, he wept at the
thought of leaving his wife and son (11:40). Shinchan's home environment
is healthy enough (which means that, at least, is out of the running as
a reason for why he's so weird). |
|
|
: A conclusion
If
the average American were to read a translation of the strip (or even
the original Japanese)
without any knowledge of Japanese culture, it wouldn't be nearly as worthwhile.
Shinchan is funny because what he chooses to do not just bends,
but snaps in half all rules of conformity and group orientation that are
such an inherent part of getting along in Japan.
Maggie Kinser Saiki, in
her article "Japan's Answer to Beavis and Butt-head", says this
is "what's most galling about Shinchan: He comes right out and says what
he's thinking, regularly abandoning
. . . for
". She goes on to say that the Japanese who have been raised on the
traditional family values found in strips like Sazae-san are often
appalled by the alternative Shinchan presents and the possibility that
such an alternative may actually exist in their society. The fuss over
Shinchan's behavior, she writes, "which mostly amounts to bad manners",
reveals much about the Japanese psyche. (Incidentally, I think Shinchan
is more akin to some of the characters on South Park than to Beavis
and Butt-head.)
Perhaps the Japanese fans
of Crayon Shinchan admire its hero not just because he has a child's
innocence and societal immunity that allows him to be so wild, but also
because they project themselves onto this ego incarnate and cheer
him on because he does what they would, in their heart of hearts, like
to try, but are not allowed to do as societal law-abiding adults.
Finally, to quote Shinchan:
. |
Works
Cited
- Iwama,
Hiroshi F. "Group Orientation in Secondary Schools".
- Saiki,
Maggie Kinser. "Japan's Answer to Beavis and Butt-head". Wall
Street Journal 11 February 1994. 12 April 1998 <http://www.flash.net/~meczilla/shinchan/wsjtext.html>.
- Singleton,
John. "Gambaru: A Japanese Cultural Theory of Learning".
- Stevens Heathon,
Harold W. The Learning Gap: Why Our Schools Are Failing and What
We Can Learn from Japanese and Chinese Education. New York: Summit
Books, 1992.
- Usui Yoshito.
Crayon Shinchan. 13 vols. Tokyo: Kabushikigaisha Futabasha, 1992-1995.
Copyright
© 1998 Nora Stevens
nora@heathens.co.nz
|